Brooklyn's Finest Pizza photo 1Brooklyn's Finest Pizza photo 2Brooklyn's Finest Pizza photo 3

Restaurants in Baker

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza

4.3
205 Google reviews$ · Inexpensive

One of 12 restaurants we've tracked near Baker.

Things to Know

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is a casual Italian pizzeria known for New York-style pizza and attentive service, located in the Denver area near Red Rocks.

Reviewers consistently praise the genuine, thoughtful service and quality pizza that rivals New York establishments, making it worth a deliberate visit rather than just a casual stop.

  • Staff goes above and beyond—one server kept pizza warm in the oven while a customer moved outside
  • Pizza quality compared favorably to New York by travelers from Kentucky
  • Specific menu standouts include the Little Italy, Italianno, New York New York pizza, eggplant rollatini, and ribeye Philly
  • Calzones have notably small amounts of filling relative to their size
  • 10-inch pizzas may look thin or frozen pizza-like to some diners

Based on Google reviews · AI summarized

Hours

Monday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Tuesday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Wednesday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Thursday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Friday: 10:30 AM – 12:00 AM

Saturday: 10:30 AM – 2:00 AM

Sunday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Open now

What Visitors Say

J

Jeremy Derr

a month ago

Everything about this afternoon was absolutely enjoyable and amazing. Al made sure we were taken care of with our pizza. Shot out to the cooks by the way on the Little italy and the italiliano. This pizza was better than the first yall!! But why we came back was the service the first time and the pizza was amazing. The lady who gave us our menus today was our server the first time. Thank you guys again for an amazing afternoon! Best vibes yall!

T

Tobbs v

2 months ago

Friends ordered the 10inch pizza. Honestly, it looks like a frozen pizza. I didn't try it. They said it was good. I ordered the new salt and pepper wings. The wings are on the smaller size. It was decent. Place has a full bar. The old fashion I got was good. The wait staff was nice and polite, which is why this place is getting a 4 instead of a 3. This place is nice if you're near by to stop by for some food and drinks, but not plan to go to. At least for me.

M

Mea Visser

8 months ago

Absolutely incredible service and amazing pizza! I stopped in and was blown away by how kind and attentive the staff were. While I was finishing my drink, I asked if I could move outside and they not only said yes—they even offered to dish my pizza into a to-go box and keep it warm in the oven until I was ready. Like, who does that? Seriously thoughtful. The drink was also delicious (and strong in the best way). Highly recommend for both the food and the genuinely welcoming vibe. Can’t wait to come back!

T

Tina Whyte

6 months ago

Found this place accidentally on our trip to red rocks from Ky. It’s hands down the best Italian food we’ve had without going to New York !! From beginning to end the place is amazing. Dont hesitate to stop in you’ll be glad you did. Shout out to Jenny for amazing service! I recommend the eggplant rollatini, New York New York pizza and ribeye Philly!!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Brooklyn's Finest Pizza worth it in Baker?

Reviewers consistently praise the genuine, thoughtful service and quality pizza that rivals New York establishments, making it worth a deliberate visit rather than just a casual stop. Known for: new york pizza without flying east.

What do visitors love about Brooklyn's Finest Pizza?

Staff goes above and beyond—one server kept pizza warm in the oven while a customer moved outside Pizza quality compared favorably to New York by travelers from Kentucky Specific menu standouts include the Little Italy, Italianno, New York New York pizza, eggplant rollatini, and ribeye Philly

Is there anything to know before visiting Brooklyn's Finest Pizza?

Calzones have notably small amounts of filling relative to their size 10-inch pizzas may look thin or frozen pizza-like to some diners

More Restaurants near Baker

Pesto ItalianoOpen

Pesto Italiano

4.7(108)

3999 S Broadway, Englewood, CO 80113, USA

Known for: Fresh italian flavors, attentive service, reasonable prices

Gallo Italian Supper Club and BakeryOpen

Gallo Italian Supper Club and Bakery

4.6(1,563)·$$$$

3470 S Broadway, Englewood, CO 80113, USA

Known for: Authentic italian food, showstopping desserts

Angelo’s TavernaOpen

Angelo’s Taverna

4.6(3,632)·$$$$

620 E 6th Ave, Denver, CO 80203, USA

Known for: Decadent italian pasta and fresh oysters