Restaurants in Baker
Gallo Italian Supper Club and Bakery
Rates above the average for restaurants near Baker — one of 12 we've tracked here.
Things to Know
Gallo Italian Supper Club and Bakery is an owner-operated Italian restaurant on Broadway known for handmade pasta, house-made pastries, and an impressive bakery case, located in Denver with a warm, family-style atmosphere and upholstered seating.
Reviewers consistently praise this as some of the best Italian food in Denver, with every dish executed flawlessly and a bakery selection that rivals dedicated pastry shops—the lobster tails and tiramisu are standout stars.
- ✓Handmade arancini, pasta dishes, and meatballs that are consistently excellent across the menu
- ✓Impressive Italian bakery case with lobster tails, tiramisu, cookies, and house-made desserts worth taking home
- ✓Warm, family-owned hospitality with attentive service and owners personally greeting guests
- ✓Comfortable, upholstered seating and inviting atmosphere that feels like dining in someone's home
- ⚠Occasional service inconsistencies reported on busy nights, though reviewers note this may not be typical
Based on Google reviews · AI summarized
Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
What Visitors Say
Steve “Stevie G.” Gallegos
5 months ago
Woah...this place is our new favorite indulgence! Greeted and seated by one of the owners, it's like being welcomed into her home. The restaurant is well staffed, and they are attentive, responsive and professional. The food is outstanding. The ambience warm, comfortable, and the most awesome chairs ever. No sitting on planks of wood, we are talking real upholstered seating here folks! Now the food...outstanding and truly Italian. And if you have ever wanted to experience a bakery - Italian style - wait till you see this place. OMG, an array of desserts and baked goods that will blow your mind and make you forget about your diet. Do it. Its worth it. If just for one night. We will definitely return and this time...we're bringing friends!
Gina E
4 months ago
Incredible dinner with framily @ Gallo Supper Club! We have not been since they reopened after the remodel. The food was fabulous!!! Especially loved the 🧄 knots, Gaspucci’s pasta (with fettuccini vs penne), italian sausage, meat calzone, limoncello, and the 🧁 dessert star of the show was the 🍓 Berry Tiramisu. Rocky describes it as strawberry shortcake meets a Chantilly cake gone wild. This was only our second time here. Not sure what was up Friday night, but there were quite a variety of service issues that put a damper on things (that I’m assuming are not normal). The food definitely made up for it. I’m giving it a 4.0 / 5.0 🌟(only reason for not giving it a 5.0 was the service) and we will be back.
Ross
5 months ago
Absolutely incredible. I very rarely go out for Italian food, and this was a special treat. Every single item was beyond delicious. Had the Arincini, the meatballs, chicken Marsala, and the chocolate lobster tail. When I say that there was not a bad item (or even a mediocre one) on the menu. I mean it. The atmosphere was comfortable, and the service was amazing. One of the best dinners I have had at any restaurant in Denver. Looking forward to coming back and trying that tiramisu
Jolinda
5 months ago
We have eaten here lots of times now....and every time getting a box full of to-go desserts. The lobster tails....vanilla, chocolate and a new raspberry flavor. Yes! All the cookies. Best Italian food in Colorado... just go immediately! We have tried a number of things on the menu and each bite absolutely delicious. Like mouth watering between bites....can't hold in the vocal mmmmmmms while chewing. Eyes closing to take it in a little more kind of good. The atmosphere and staff are perfection. Family feel in all the ways. The bread service is a must! Go Hungry! If you are a lover of the sweet baked yummy things life has....Get here faster! Like nibble on for days sort of yummy! We've had the fried ravioli, lasagna, the branzino, carbonara and fettuccine Alfredo, chicken parm, chicken picata....oooooo so good. Look at the picks..get ready! Everything is Absolutely perfect! 🫶 The staff is sooo friendly! They even made me a chocolate martini....that wasn't on the menu! Everything about this place is a win!
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Gallo Italian Supper Club and Bakery worth it in Baker?
Reviewers consistently praise this as some of the best Italian food in Denver, with every dish executed flawlessly and a bakery selection that rivals dedicated pastry shops—the lobster tails and tiramisu are standout stars. Known for: authentic italian food, showstopping desserts.
What do visitors love about Gallo Italian Supper Club and Bakery?
Handmade arancini, pasta dishes, and meatballs that are consistently excellent across the menu Impressive Italian bakery case with lobster tails, tiramisu, cookies, and house-made desserts worth taking home Warm, family-owned hospitality with attentive service and owners personally greeting guests Comfortable, upholstered seating and inviting atmosphere that feels like dining in someone's home
Is there anything to know before visiting Gallo Italian Supper Club and Bakery?
Occasional service inconsistencies reported on busy nights, though reviewers note this may not be typical
More Restaurants near Baker
Pesto Italiano
3999 S Broadway, Englewood, CO 80113, USA
Known for: Fresh italian flavors, attentive service, reasonable prices
Angelo’s Taverna
620 E 6th Ave, Denver, CO 80203, USA
Known for: Decadent italian pasta and fresh oysters
Joyce's Famous Pizza
2120 S Broadway, Denver, CO 80210, USA
Known for: Authentic ny pizza, denver landmark


