Cosmo's Pizza photo 1Cosmo's Pizza photo 2Cosmo's Pizza photo 3

Restaurants in Highlands

Cosmo's Pizza

4.5
774 Google reviews

One of 10 restaurants we've tracked near Highlands.

Things to Know

Cosmo's Pizza is a New York-style pizzeria in Denver known for generous slices and ingredient-forward pies, located with shared parking and both indoor and outdoor seating.

Reviewers praise the authentic New York-style crust, generous slice sizes, and lunch specials, though the pizza style—chewy crust and sweeter sauce—won't appeal to everyone.

  • Large slices at reasonable prices, especially the two-slice lunch special
  • Authentic New York-style crust with a chewy texture and nice ingredient combinations
  • Attentive staff and quick service, even during busy times
  • The sweet and spicy sauce and thick, dense dough aren't to all tastes
  • Crust can be floppy enough to require folding, and pricing escalates quickly with added toppings

Based on Google reviews · AI summarized

Hours

Monday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Thursday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM

Friday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM

Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM

Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Open now

What Visitors Say

C

C R

a month ago

The pizza itself wasn't all that great. I got plain cheese. The slices are pricey at $4.25/plain cheese but they are pretty big. They have plenty of indoor and outside seating avail. The parking lot is like of small and it's shared with another business. The staff was attentive and check out was fairly quick. I dont like the sauce(sweeter and spicy) they used and the dough( thick and dense) isn't my fav. I will not be back due to those reasons.

B

Burt

4 months ago

I've driven past Cosmo Pizza and finally decided to stop in and grab a slice. They're a New York style pizza with some nice ingredient combinations in the glass case up front, pricing is based on the number of ingredients which can get expensive quick. Overall, the slice was a good size, the crust had a slight chewy texture to it, the bottom was slightly floppy so I had to eat the pizza slice folded in half (like a calzone), the sauce was mild and the toppings were as well.

L

Lou Lou

3 months ago

Stopped by Cosmo’s Pizza in Denver and was not disappointed. The large pizza tasted great and hit the spot. Solid quality and flavor; I’d absolutely go back again next time I’m in Denver.

N

Nicole Weiss

4 months ago

Couldn't resist stopping at this place as I walked by while exploring from out of state. Had to have the two slice lunch special, absolute steal of a deal. Very busy for a good reason because the pizzas are delicious!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cosmo's Pizza worth it in Highlands?

Reviewers praise the authentic New York-style crust, generous slice sizes, and lunch specials, though the pizza style—chewy crust and sweeter sauce—won't appeal to everyone. Known for: new york style pizza, denver prices.

What do visitors love about Cosmo's Pizza?

Large slices at reasonable prices, especially the two-slice lunch special Authentic New York-style crust with a chewy texture and nice ingredient combinations Attentive staff and quick service, even during busy times

Is there anything to know before visiting Cosmo's Pizza?

The sweet and spicy sauce and thick, dense dough aren't to all tastes Crust can be floppy enough to require folding, and pricing escalates quickly with added toppings

More Restaurants near Highlands

Outside PizzaOpen

Outside Pizza

4.9(83)

3257 Lowell Blvd, Denver, CO 80211, USA

Known for: Creative wood-fired pizza, serious pickle pie

The Pizza BanditOpen

The Pizza Bandit

4.8(132)

3200 N Pecos St unit 102 (first floor, Denver, CO 80211, USA

Known for: Wood-fired pizza with perfect charred crust

Blue Pan PizzaOpen

Blue Pan Pizza

4.6(2,151)·$$$$

3934 W 32nd Ave, Denver, CO 80212, USA

Known for: Detroit-style pizza with crunchy, perfect edges