Pizza Alley photo 1Pizza Alley photo 2Pizza Alley photo 3

Restaurants in Highlands

Pizza Alley

4.5
873 Google reviews$ · Inexpensive

One of 10 restaurants we've tracked near Highlands.

Things to Know

Pizza Alley is a casual pizzeria in Highland known for its thin, crispy crust and New York-style slices at reasonable prices, with a recently renovated space and welcoming staff.

Reviewers consistently praise the thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings on their New York-style slices, though some longtime customers note the pizza tastes different under new ownership.

  • thin, crispy crust with perfectly melted cheese and fresh toppings
  • big, satisfying New York-style slices at fair prices
  • genuinely welcoming and nice staff
  • the Alley slice (supreme style) is a standout
  • pizza recipe has changed since new ownership, disappointing longtime customers
  • wings are no longer comparable to how they used to be

Based on Google reviews · AI summarized

Hours

Monday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Tuesday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Wednesday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Thursday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Friday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Saturday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Sunday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Open now

What Visitors Say

C

Cyrene Gomez

3 weeks ago

We ordered a half and half pizza which was very flavorful and satisfying. Even crust was really thin and crispy. Best pizza in Highland for the price for sure. The staff were so welcoming and genuinely nice. I”ll definitely back to try their calzones.

V

Vanaiah Jasmine

6 months ago

Pizza Alley has always been apart of my childhood! My grandma would take us in for their lunch special very often. We loved it! We visited today since the new ownership and renovations. My garden salad and breadsticks tasted as good as I remember! As far as the pizza, it’s not the same but still yummy. We used to love the wings, but now they aren’t even comparable. All in all the food was decent. The vibes inside are kind of gentrified, I miss the old pizza alley taste and looks. Happy it’s back though.

T

The Intellectual Observer

2 months ago

Loved the Alley slice, it was a big New York style supreme slice. Had a salad as well very good. Definitely coming back, try it out if you're in the mood for Pizza Time!

D

Diwash Ale

a month ago

Pizza Alley delivered an outstanding dining experience for me. I tried three different menu items which included a pepperoni slice and extra cheese pizza and sausage slice and I found everything to be delicious. The crust reached the ideal texture because the cheese melted perfectly and the toppings maintained their fresh and tasty quality. The restaurant provides an ideal atmosphere for customers who want to enjoy a fast pizza slice while the dining space creates an enjoyable atmosphere. I will return to this place because I enjoyed it so much. This restaurant requires your presence if you have pizza cravings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pizza Alley worth it in Highlands?

Reviewers consistently praise the thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings on their New York-style slices, though some longtime customers note the pizza tastes different under new ownership. Known for: thin crust, supreme slices, highland favorite.

What do visitors love about Pizza Alley?

thin, crispy crust with perfectly melted cheese and fresh toppings big, satisfying New York-style slices at fair prices genuinely welcoming and nice staff the Alley slice (supreme style) is a standout

Is there anything to know before visiting Pizza Alley?

pizza recipe has changed since new ownership, disappointing longtime customers wings are no longer comparable to how they used to be

More Restaurants near Highlands

Outside PizzaOpen

Outside Pizza

4.9(83)

3257 Lowell Blvd, Denver, CO 80211, USA

Known for: Creative wood-fired pizza, serious pickle pie

The Pizza BanditOpen

The Pizza Bandit

4.8(132)

3200 N Pecos St unit 102 (first floor, Denver, CO 80211, USA

Known for: Wood-fired pizza with perfect charred crust

Blue Pan PizzaOpen

Blue Pan Pizza

4.6(2,151)·$$$$

3934 W 32nd Ave, Denver, CO 80212, USA

Known for: Detroit-style pizza with crunchy, perfect edges