Florence Supper Club

Florence Supper Club is my favorite Italian meal I’ve had in Denver. It’s classic, comforting, and executed with so much care. Everything feels intentional without feeling fussy. From the team behind Odell’s Bagels, this restaurant takes a traditional Italian supper club approach and absolutely nails it. The menu is familiar in the best way, but every dish is elevated through quality and technique. We ordered across the menu, including their famous meatballs, multiple pasta dishes, veal parmesan, and several desserts. Every plate was well balanced, rich without being heavy, and clearly made with confidence. The spicy rigatoni alla vodka, linguini vongole, and lasagna were all standouts, but honestly there wasn’t a single dish I wouldn’t order again. Even the desserts were memorable, especially the tiramisu and cheesecake. Florence Supper Club is the kind of place that feels timeless. It’s perfect for a special dinner, a long meal with friends, or when you just want really good Italian food done right. I’m genuinely excited to have a restaurant like this in Denver.

I’m still dreaming about this place! I typically am a bit choosy when it comes to pasta, but this is a place I will absolutely be coming back to. We ordered the focaccia, Caesar salad, meatballs, chicken parm, spicy vodka rigatoni, orecchiette with sausage, rigatoni bolognese (the lasagna was sold out), and all the desserts. I have to say everything was delicious. The meatballs are a must as they are well seasoned and tender (have them with the focaccia), the chicken parm was perfectly crisp and delicious, you could eat more than a bowl of the Caesar, and the pastas were sensational. My favorite was the spicy vodka rigatoni! The desserts were delicious, can’t go wrong with ordering any of them, but if you’re having a hard time choosing I would recommend the tiramisu or the cheesecake.

This place is great for authentic Italian food! The service is phenomenal. Carter was incredibly friendly with great wine recommendations. The focaccia and Cesar salad were the best I’ve had in Denver! The vongole and spicy rigatoni alla vodka were also great! Highly recommend!!!

I’ve lived in Denver area for 10 years (came from NJ/NYC), and this is the best Italian I’ve had in Denver by far. The only contender was Marcella’s, and that went out of biz years ago (RIP). Loved the small family-owned vibe, classic deco, and over-the-top service. I believe our server was Sally? She was so attentive and friendly. The food was amazinggg. Definitely order family-style and share everything. We got the Caesar salad, chicken parm, vodka rigatoni, broccoli rabe (smoky and bitter, in a good way), cheesecake, and cappuccino. I would get all of them again.