Redeemer Pizza photo 1Redeemer Pizza photo 2Redeemer Pizza photo 3

Restaurants in Cole

Redeemer Pizza

4.3
707 Google reviews$$ · Moderate

One of 15 restaurants we've tracked near Cole.

Things to Know

Redeemer Pizza is a neighborhood pizzeria known for its crispy wood-fired crust, creative pizza builds, and made-to-order sandwiches, located in Denver with delivery and dine-in options.

Reviewers love the quality ingredients and care in execution—from cheese-filled garlic knots with hot honey to fresh-cooked chicken sandwiches—though consistency with crispiness levels varies between visits.

  • Garlic knots are cheese-filled and come with addictive hot honey dip
  • Homemade-tasting ranch dressing that stands out on its own
  • Chicken Caesar Salad Hoagie features juicy, crispy made-to-order chicken and exceptional bread
  • Fast pickup times (around 20 minutes)
  • Customizable pizzas with quality toppings like rosemary almond crunch and fresh sausage
  • Casual hole-in-the-wall vibe with wooden booth seating
  • Pizza can sometimes arrive too crispy or burnt, especially the pepperoni—consistency is hit or miss
  • Some pizzas run dry and may need extra sauce
  • Occasional quality control issues with garlic knots (some reported them slightly raw inside)

Based on Google reviews · AI summarized

Hours

Monday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Friday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM

Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM

Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Open now

What Visitors Say

S

Sean Berry

a month ago

I’ve had pizza from a lot of places in Denver, and we weren’t wanting to go out so we decided to order pizza out and we were looking for a place that was different and that delivered, they have a great menu where you can order any kind of pizza build your own pizza etc. So we decided to go with just the traditional pepperoni pizza, we also ordered their garlic knots which were surprisingly delicious. Loved that they put mozzarella cheese on the inside of the garlic knots, the crust on the pizza was perfect and overall, we were extremely happy with our order. Will definitely try their other pizzas and look forward to going there in person. We will definitely be getting pizza here again, and yes, if you’re looking for a place to order pizza for delivery, I would highly recommend this place.

l

lily nichols

a month ago

This place was recommended to me and it was good!! I got the special which was NY style slice w peppers, onion and sausage. And also a regular Pepperoni. We got the garlic knots too, which we discovered were cheese filled, but unfortunately a little raw in some.. when eating around that, though, they were good. They came with a hot honey dip that was very good on them. Being from the midwest, I am a LOVER of ranch and this place must make their own or buy local because it tastes so fresh, you can taste dill and the spices . 10/10 for just the ranch. Pizza was good, nice crust , a little greasy as you can see, but nothing a new napkins can’t fix. The vibe was cool, felt like a whole in the wall, wooden booth seating.

R

Ryan Garcia

a month ago

Went to Redeemer Pizza to try the Chicken Caesar Salad Hoagie and it absolutely lived up to the hype 🔥 Made to order. This is not some pre-cooked chicken sitting under a heat lamp. This was juicy, crispy, and seasoned perfectly. The bread 🍞? Unreal. Soft inside, slight crunch outside. Everything just worked. Super filling and 100% worth the price. They crushed it.

A

Anthony Marohn

3 months ago

Wanted to try this place since I just moved into the neighborhood. My order was super quick….maybe 20 mins from the time I ordered to pick up. Went with the Sausage and Squash pizza. Really loved this concept. The rosemary almond crunch on top added a nice flavor. I also ordered extra sausage and definitely got that!!! My only complaint was the pizza was very dry. Needed extra sauce on this one. Will I go again? Yes!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Redeemer Pizza worth it in Cole?

Reviewers love the quality ingredients and care in execution—from cheese-filled garlic knots with hot honey to fresh-cooked chicken sandwiches—though consistency with crispiness levels varies between visits. Known for: crispy crust pizza with creative toppings.

What do visitors love about Redeemer Pizza?

Garlic knots are cheese-filled and come with addictive hot honey dip Homemade-tasting ranch dressing that stands out on its own Chicken Caesar Salad Hoagie features juicy, crispy made-to-order chicken and exceptional bread Fast pickup times (around 20 minutes) Customizable pizzas with quality toppings like rosemary almond crunch and fresh sausage Casual hole-in-the-wall vibe with wooden booth seating

Is there anything to know before visiting Redeemer Pizza?

Pizza can sometimes arrive too crispy or burnt, especially the pepperoni—consistency is hit or miss Some pizzas run dry and may need extra sauce Occasional quality control issues with garlic knots (some reported them slightly raw inside)

More Restaurants near Cole

Pizza Cucina DenverClosed

Pizza Cucina Denver

4.9(159)·$$$$

2934 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80206, USA

Known for: Fresh pizza with generous toppings always

JoeyParm's PizzaClosed

JoeyParm's Pizza

4.9(149)·$$$$

2854 Larimer St, Denver, CO 80205, USA

Known for: Neapolitan pizza that rivals new york

Oblio'sOpen

Oblio's

4.8(2,155)·$$$$

6115 E 22nd Ave, Denver, CO 80207, USA

Known for: Wood-fired pizza worth the drive