Granny Scott's Pie Shop

Horrible experience! My family recently moved close by and has been exploring the shops in these shopping centers. My husband and I came across this pie shop, and let me tell you, we love our sweets! 😋 Unfortunately, this was our first and last time coming here. We ordered two slices of pie to try it out: pumpkin cheesecake and caramel apple. They are very small and cost $5.99 per slice. The first slice we got of the caramel apple was half a slice and looked like it was half-eaten or something. I asked the employee if he would give me a full slice, not a half slice. It was a young boy who helped us; he was extremely rude. He immediately got irritated and insisted it WAS a full slice and started slamming stuff around. The whole experience was just horrible! BE AWARE!! NOT WORTH IT!!

I ordered the Strawberry Rhubarb pie. Between the cost of the pie and the Lyft it cost me $72. See the photos of what my pie looked like and the one in their picture. I didn't open the box until I got home. I needed it at 11 am the next day for my son's birthday dinner. I was embarrassed how it looked. I gave it three stars because my son said it tasted good. I don't know how to change the date on the review. This happened in April 2025.

I love a good homemade pie. I couldn't stop next door for coffee and not check out this bakery. Everything looked and smelled amazing. I bought a half dozen treats for my friends from here, from the lemon poppy muffins to different slices of pie and banana bread. Everything was delicious! 10/10 experience here. I can't wait to come back and try the lunch menu sandwiches and quiche.

This place really does feel like eating pie in your grandma's kitchen! My fiance and I went in to purchase a variety or pie slices to sample, and after just one bite we were sold. Definitely try the Dutch Apple and the Pecan, they are not just the best I've had of their kind but likely the two best pies I've ever had period. They also offer a variety of other baked goods and drinks, and everything is reasonably priced. And all employees were friendly and helpful. Highly recommend!!!