Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St.

We preordered 2 pies for Christmas and picked them up the day before. I did order weeks in advance and the pick up process was as easy as possible the Silk pie was my favorite and would get the apple crisp again. I would recommend this bakery and I’m already thinking of a reason to go back for a key lime pie!

They have a decent but small selection of pies. Unfortunately, the French silk pie didn’t really deliver. The personal size is about $8 and very tiny for the price, which already felt steep. We went with the slightly larger one at $13 instead, but even then, the quality didn’t quite justify the cost.

These are the best pies ever! I will definitely come in again. They didnt have a huge selection but, you can pre order some.

I ordered 3 pies for Thanksgiving. The french silk, the pumpkin pie, and the apple bourbon crumble. The french silk was a huge hit and incredibly delicious, and so was the apple bourbon crumble (although a little too crumbly to be a pie, it fell apart immediately and was hard to serve in slices but still amazing!) The pumpkin was the only pie that was a little disappointing. The one I got was extremely unappetizing looking, the crust was super uneven and wonky, and there was pie filling over the edge. It was so ugly that most of my family didn’t want to eat it lol. It definitely didn’t look like the photos and also didn’t have the little whipped cream dollop in the center.